The Legal Examiner Affiliate Network The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner search feed instagram google-plus avvo phone envelope checkmark mail-reply spinner error close
Skip to main content

Children . . . our most precious resource." We all agree with this statement, don’t we? Then why do we, myself included, allow our children to ride to and from school every day on school busses, the majority of which do not have seatbelts?

In this day of motor vehicle technology and safety, I cannot understand how engineers cannot install seatbelts in school busses that can adequately protect child-passengers. In my automobile injury law practice, I have seen a number of cases involving school bus accidents. Because of their size and design, school buses are susceptible to rollover crashes. In most rollover crashes, death or serious injury occurs because unrestrained passengers get ejected from the bus or suffer blunt-force trauma from striking the interior of the bus during the crash. Think about some of the safety features our personal cars, trucks and SUVs have today such as front, side and window curtain airbags, anti-lock brakes, stability traction control and anti-rollover stabilization, to name a few. Even our seatbelts have advanced over the years. Still, an automobile safety engineer has not figured out a way to install seatbelts in all school busses? I don’t get it.

Apparently, opponents of seatbelts argue that school busses are safe they way they are designed now (which is fairly unchanged since the late 1970s). They claim that the design principle of "compartmentalization," i.e., the high-backed, closely positioned seats in school busses provide the best safety option for children in crashes. Advocates of seatbelts seem to suggest, however, that most school busses don’t have seatbelts because of economic issues and school districts’ reluctance to enforce the use of the same by students. I ask: “shouldn’t safety come first?”

One Comment

  1. Gravatar for tre

    Yes, safety should come first!

    I have struggled for a few years now to understand why school busses do not have seatbelts. There is some type of safety restraint on AMUSEMENT PARK/CARNIVAL RIDES, but for some reason school busses aren't as important. Compartmentalization does not protect any passenger when a bus rolls over or swerves, or even when a frontal impact accident occurs at moderate to high speeds.

    As a concerned parent, I have compiled enough research, including NHTSA, NTSB and Ins. Inst. reports, specific accident reports and personal observations, to conclude that school busses without seat belts are so unsafe that I have committed to driving my kids to/from school and on every field trip. [My employer is very good, but my kids even fight me because of peer pressure at school.]

    Unfortunately, school busses are a necessary evil; they can be safe if folks will just listen to reason [and real world facts].

Comments are closed.