The Legal Examiner Affiliate Network The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner search instagram avvo phone envelope checkmark mail-reply spinner error close The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner
Skip to main content


While Cardinal Theodore McCarrick’s entire life as a priest, a bishop, and a cardinal was lived on the East Coast, he abused one boy in California after the family had moved Hillsborough, California in 1971.

A few days ago, the NY Times broke the story that Cardinal McCarrick’s predations were not exclusively young men preparing to be priests.  James (the abuse survivor spoke with the Times using only his first name in order to protect his family) agreed to an interview with the Times after revelations that McCarrick had abused an 11 year old boy in a parish in NY.  James told the newspaper his saga of abuse lasted decades.

According to the NY Times, “By then, James said, Father McCarrick had begun abusing him sexually. When he was 13, he said, the priest first touched his penis. At 14, he said, Father McCarrick masturbated him in a beach parking lot. When he was 15, James said, Father McCarrick took him to a restaurant in San Francisco, the Tonga Room, and poured vodka in his drinks. He then brought him back to his hotel room and masturbated him and brought himself to orgasm, James said.”

This California connection may pose new legal problems for McCarrick who up until now has been able to avoid answering for his behavior due to statutes of limitations.  The police report James completed has been forwarded to law enforcement in San Francisco for sex crimes investigators to research and determine if McCarrick can be charged in California.

The new McCarrick revelations also pose a problem for Pope Francis who is now faced with what to do with an elderly cardinal of the church who sexually abused children.  As the pope, Francis has broad authority to punish McCarrick either by defrocking him (unlikely) or stripping him of his cardinalatial title.  McCarrick has already been banned from public ministry.


One Comment

  1. Gravatar for Thomas Carney
    Thomas Carney

    There has been a long standing canon (rule of law) in the Catholic Church (and the Orthodox Church) to NEVER ordain homosexuals. This canon has been ignored for decades. Now we're seeing the fruits of this lack of enforcement. In 1961 the Vatican sent a decree to the American and Canadian bishops re-iterating the Church's long-standing ban against ordaining homosexuals to even minor (lector, exorcist, sub-deacon) Holy Orders and major Holy Orders (deacon, priest, bishop). In those pre-Vatican II days, the Church in Rome only moved when necessary. The Vatican in 1961 would not have issued that decree unless there was a problem.

Comments for this article are closed.