The Legal Examiner Affiliate Network The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner search instagram avvo phone envelope checkmark mail-reply spinner error close The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner The Legal Examiner
Skip to main content
Young priest with rosary beads on light background

As the deadline for filing a sexual abuse lawsuit in California nears its expiration on December 31, 2022, names of new priest not previously named as sexual abusers is emerging.  Recently, 10 names of priests serving primarily in the Archdiocese of San Francisco and Oakland have surfaced as named perpetrators in filed sexual abuse lawsuits in Alameda County.

The 14 accused priests came to light in a torrent of litigation unleashed by Assembly Bill 218, which opened a three-year window from 2020-2022 during which adults who say they were abused long ago as children are allowed to sue. Attorneys had predicted the law would generate thousands of lawsuits against institutions including the Boy Scouts and Catholic Church.

These ten priests are:

  • John A. Lynch, San Francisco
  • Christian Sandholdt, San Francisco
  • Robert Gemmet, San Francisco
  • Joseph Watt in San Francisco.
  • John Francis Scanlon, Oakland
  • Domingos S. Jacques, Oakland
  • Benedict Reams, Moraga
  • Sister M. Rosella McConnell, Berkeley
  • Elwood Geary, San Jose
  • Henry Hall, Monterey
  • James F. Corley, Santa Rosa
  • Sidney P. Hall, Sacramento
  • William Dodson, Fresno
  • Robert H. Lewis, Dinuba

This is significant because the Archdiocese of San Francisco has refused to release a list of priests, brothers, and religious sister accused of sexual abuse.  The other northern California dioceses have been somewhat more compliant in terms of transparency and public disclosure.

Melanie Sakoda, survivor support coordinator for SNAP, said she wasn’t surprised about the new names. She said SNAP already was aware of most of the newly identified priests except for Dodson, Jacque and Lewis.

“On the lists released by dioceses, there are usually names missing,” Sakoda said. “Some are already out in the public — just not named by the diocese — but we also hear from survivors that they had reported their abuse to the bishop, but the perpetrator does not appear on the list. The diocese has simply dismissed their outcries.”

“The fact that the location of the 14 are unknown, as well as whether they still have access to children, is an extremely dangerous situation,” Sakoda said. “Many Catholic priests who were removed from ministry for preying on children went on to work in schools, as counselors, or in other positions where they could have additional victims.”

Less than a month remains before the deadline closes on December 31, 2022.  If you or a loved one were sexually abused by a Catholic priest, brother, or religious sister as a minor (regardless of when the abuse occurred in the past), I urge you to come forward and seek justice and healing before it is too late.  Once the window of opportunity closes, you may be forever barred from seeking redress for these horrific crimes in the future.  Act now!

The Clergy Sexual Abuse Crisis


Comments for this article are closed.